Just a fear days ago, Magic players could pick up Great Whale in near mint condition for under $20 a pop. Following the recent Nauctis: The Sunken Realm Commander leaks, the Reserved List card has seen a massive price spike, with the cheapest near mint TCGplayer listing now sitting at $180.
Even heavily played copies are listed for at least $69.99, a steep increase for a reserved list card that was relatively affordable last week.
The buying started on November 16, shortly after two new Commander cards from Nauctis leaked online. According to MTG Rocks, 54 copies sold on TCGplayer that day alone, compared with just one or two daily sales beforehand.
The sudden demand has also caught the attention of MTG finance trackers. MTGStocks reported an average listing price of $195, although that figure does not represent completed sales.
Why Great Whale Is Suddenly in Demand

Great Whale is a seven mana 5/5 creature from 1998’s Urza’s Saga. When it enters the battlefield, you untap up to seven lands, effectively refunding its mana cost if you cast it normally.
That ability has long made the card useful in Commander combo decks, but the upcoming Terrors of the Abyss precon gives players several new reasons to run it.
As we reported earlier this week, two leaked Sultai commanders introduce Sea Monsters as a new grouping that includes Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, and Whales.

One of those commanders, Noble Sea Serpent, can return a Sea Monster from your graveyard to the battlefield at the beginning of your end step. That means you can reanimate Great Whale without paying its mana cost, untapping seven lands in the process.
The alternate commander, Zex, Ravenist Devotee, gives Sea Monster spells emerge. By sacrificing another creature, players can reduce the cost of casting Great Whale, then untap seven lands when it enters.

There is also synergy with the recently revealed Salinae, the Ocean Mother, which can copy creature spells. Copying Great Whale gives players two creatures that each untap seven lands when they enter.

Interest in the card picked up after an MTG finance discussion highlighted its potential. Several players reported buying copies.
Will the $180 Price Hold?
Right now there is a supply shortage in the US, and some countries have copies still around $20-$50.
What makes this spike different from most Commander buyouts is that Great Whale is on Wizards’ Reserved List. Its only tournament legal printing came in Urza’s Saga, and Wizards’ current policy prevents another one.
Reserve list cards often go through buyouts, which spike the price as buyers work through limited supply. But, soon after, people start rummaging through their collection and old copies come online again, eventually driving the price back down. Take a look at Second Chance price data from MTG Goldfish for example.

Now that the buyout has already happened for Great Whale, new cards coming into the market are likely to push the price down.
With the Terrors of the Abyss precon arriving in February 2027, players have several months before they can actually build around the new commanders.
ALSO READ: MTG Slivers Are Coming Back, Aaron Forsythe Confirms at MagicCon Atlanta